Pricing

Raising Your Prices Without Losing Good Customers

Don't put one flat increase on everything. Split each product line into blank, decoration, setup, freight and labor, find the lines that fall short of your margin floor, and move those first. Give your best repeat accounts a smaller or later step. Then send a short, dated notice with an effective date, and honor open quotes until they expire.

Dave
DavePublished 7 min read
In this article 7 sections
  1. Why a flat increase is the wrong tool
  2. Step one: check that your costs have really moved
  3. Step two: build the price review worksheet
  4. Step three: rank lines and tiers, then decide the step
  5. Step four: tighten the edges that leak
  6. Step five: tell customers, briefly
  7. Make it a habit, not an event
A $20.40 polo is priced at $34.00, $31.00 or $29.00 by customer tier, and anchors still beat the old $26.00.

Your blank costs went up, freight went up, and your price list has barely moved. Every time you think about raising prices you picture your best corporate account going quiet, so you leave it for another quarter and the gap grows.

The short answer is to stop thinking about “a price increase” and run a staged price review. Break each line into its parts, find where the margin has slipped, move the worst lines first, protect your anchor accounts with a smaller step, and tell customers plainly with a date. This article gives you a worksheet you can fill in this week and a notice you can adapt.

Why a flat increase is the wrong tool

Adding the same percentage to everything feels fair and simple, but it ignores how decorated products are priced. A polo order has a blank cost, a decoration charge, a setup or digitizing fee, freight and packaging, and labor. Each of those moves at a different speed. Your blank cost may have jumped while your embroidery run charge is already priced where the market sits.

A flat increase overcharges on the lines that were fine and still undercharges on the lines that were bleeding. It also hands customers one big number to react to. A line-by-line review lets you move less overall while recovering more margin.

A steel spike holding a wad of supplier invoices with three sheets fanned out beside it and a steel ruler on a worn office desk.
The latest supplier invoices come off the spike to confirm the cost increase is real before a price moves.

Step one: check that your costs have really moved

Before you change anything, confirm the increase is real and not a single bad invoice. Pull your last three supplier invoices for your top blanks and compare them with what’s in your price list. For a wider view, the BLS Producer Price Index tracks the average change in the selling prices that domestic producers receive, with industry series you can look up to see whether input prices in your categories are climbing.

Then make sure your cost figure is complete. A cost that leaves out freight, packaging and the labor to pick, hoop, trim and bag a garment will hide exactly the erosion you’re trying to find. Keep shop overhead (rent, software, the owner’s salary) out of the per-unit job cost and cover it with your margin floor. That way nothing gets counted twice.

Step two: build the price review worksheet

Set up one row per product line you sell regularly. A spreadsheet is enough. The columns:

Column What goes in it
Line e.g. embroidered polo, left chest
Blank cost (now) Latest invoice price, not last year’s
Decoration cost Thread, backing, ink, transfer, per unit
Freight and packaging Per unit, allocated from the order
Direct labor Per unit, at your loaded hourly rate
Total job cost Sum of the four above
Current price What the customer pays per unit
Current margin (Price minus cost) divided by price
Margin floor The lowest margin you’ll accept
Price at floor Cost divided by (1 minus floor)
Gap Price at floor minus current price
Customer tier Anchor, regular or occasional

Two cautions before you fill it in. First, margin and markup aren’t the same thing. Markup is profit as a share of cost; margin is profit as a share of price, so the same profit always shows as a smaller margin than markup, and a markup that feels fair can leave you under your floor. Second, list setup, screen, digitizing and rush fees as their own rows. They’re separate levers, and you can sometimes recover a lot of margin there without touching the unit price customers compare.

Worked example

An embroidered polo used to cost $12.00 for the blank, $4.00 for decoration, $1.20 for freight and packaging, and $2.00 for direct labor. That’s a total job cost of $19.20, and it sold at $26.00, a margin of 26.2%.

The blank is now 10% higher at $13.20, so total cost is $20.40. At the old $26.00 price, margin falls to 21.5% ($5.60 of profit on $26.00).

With a margin floor of 40%, the price at floor is $20.40 divided by 0.60, which is $34.00. That’s a gap of $8.00 per polo, nearly a 31% increase on the old price. You can’t put that on every customer in one step without a shock, which is why the next step stages it.

All figures are illustrative. Use your own invoices and your own floor.

Notice what the example shows. The line was under the floor before the blank went up. That’s the cost of skipping small yearly reviews: one cost change turns a quiet shortfall into a catch-up increase that’s hard to send.

Step three: rank lines and tiers, then decide the step

Sort the worksheet by gap, largest first. Then look at each line through your customer tiers. A simple tiering is enough: anchor accounts (your top repeat customers by revenue), regular accounts, and occasional or one-off buyers.

Use this decision rule:

  • Big gap, occasional buyers: move to the price at floor now. These jobs are frequently the low-margin, high-effort ones, and a one-off buyer has no history at the old price.
  • Big gap, regular accounts: move most of the way now and close the rest at your next review.
  • Big gap, anchor accounts: take a smaller first step, tell them personally, and schedule the second step.
  • Small or no gap: leave the unit price alone. Check setup and rush fees instead.

Worked example

Staging the polo that now costs $20.40 from the previous example: occasional buyers move to $34.00 (40.0% margin) and are done. Regular accounts move to $31.00 (34.2% margin) with a review in six months. Anchor accounts move to $29.00 (29.7% margin) with a second step in six months.

The anchor price still beats the old $26.00 by $3.00 per polo. At an unchanged volume of 300 polos a year, the first step adds $900 on an annualized basis; the amount recovered before the six-month review depends on how many polos are ordered during that period. The anchor tier sits below the floor for now, by choice and with an end date.

Illustrative figures only.

The important part is the end date. A protected price with no review date becomes the new permanent price.

Step four: tighten the edges that leak

A few changes recover margin without anyone looking at a unit price:

  • Shorten quote validity when blank and freight prices are moving. A quote that holds for 90 days on a volatile blank means you take the risk.
  • Retire old price lists and saved quotes. Find every PDF, email template and saved quote that carries the old prices and replace or expire it. If old numbers are still in circulation after the change, you’ll end up honoring them.
  • Review setup and digitizing fees against the time they actually take. Decoration pricing covers where setup and run charges hide margin.
  • Check your minimums. If small orders are the lines furthest under the floor, a minimum order quantity may solve the problem better than a price change.

Step five: tell customers, briefly

Give customers a clear effective date with enough lead time to place orders at current prices. Honor every open quote until it expires. Call your anchor accounts before the written notice goes out so they hear it from you, not from a mass email. On the call, give the date, name the lines affected and offer to bring forward any upcoming orders. Don’t itemize your costs.

Keep the notice short. A long justification or a string of apologies reads as an invitation to negotiate. Say what’s changing, when, and what stays the same.

Customer notice template

Subject: Updated pricing from [effective date]

Hi [first name],

From [effective date], our prices for [product lines] will change. Your updated price list is attached.

Any quote we have already sent you will be honored until its expiry date, and orders confirmed before [effective date] are at current prices.

If you’d like to place a reorder before then, or talk through your upcoming orders, reply here or call us on [number].

Thanks for your continued business, [Name]

For an anchor account, the phone call does the explaining and the email confirms the date. Check any commitments in existing customer agreements before you send.

Make it a habit, not an event

The catch-up increase in the worked example happened because the line was never reviewed. Put the worksheet on the calendar twice a year and whenever a major supplier announces a change. Small, regular moves are easier to send and easier for customers to absorb than one large one. For the full method behind setting prices in the first place, see the pricing guide.

This week, pick your ten highest-volume lines, fill in the worksheet with current invoice costs, and mark every row below your floor. That list is your price review.

Get the margin calculator Use the profit margin calculator to work out landed cost, margin and markup per line and flag the rows that need a price review.

Frequently asked questions

What if an anchor customer pushes back on the first step?

Ask which orders are coming up and offer to lock the current price on a specific confirmed order before the effective date. That gives them something concrete without moving your new price list.

Should I raise prices on lines that are already above my floor?

Leave the unit price alone and look at setup, digitizing and rush fees on those lines instead. If those fees are also covering their time, those lines don't need to move.

Do I need to show customers my cost breakdown?

No. The notice says what changes and when. Your worksheet is an internal tool for deciding the step, not something to defend line by line with the customer.

Dave

Dave

Dave writes for TaggIQ about running a profitable print, promo, sign and embroidery business: costing and estimating, margins, production flow, order workflows, pricing decisions and keeping customers coming back.

AI agents

Which AI agent handles this?

Quote Agent Proposed build

Every quote followed up. Stops the moment they reply.

Quotes go out, and follow-up happens when someone has time. One customer gets three reminders and another gets none.

  • Picks up quotes with no reply after the number of days you choose
  • Reads the quote, the thread and the customer history before writing
  • Drafts a follow-up in your voice, with stock or price-break context
See how the Quote Agent works

Two ways to start

One agent on your current tools
A setup fee plus a monthly agent fee, scoped after a demo and a follow-up workflow discussion.
The TaggIQ platform
Quotes, orders, production and invoicing in one platform, with AI that drafts alongside your team. 14-day free trial.

See all AI agents and what each one does.

Find the first job an AI agent can take off your plate.

Start with one agent on the tools you already use, or run the whole workflow in TaggIQ with a 14-day free trial.

  • A guided platform demo
  • No card for the trial
  • Cancel anytime